Highest penalty percentage (5+ penalties)

#	Player	Taken	Scored	Missed	% Success
1	Danny Murphy	8	8	0	100%
2	Mark Walters	6	6	0	100%
3	John Aldridge	18	17	1	94.44%
4	Jan Mølby	45	42	3	93.33%
5	James Milner	21	19	2	90.48%
6	Willie Fagan	10	9	1	90%
7	Willie Stevenson	9	8	1	88.89%
8	Jack Parkinson	7	6	1	85.71%
9	Mohamed Salah	53	45	8	84.91%
10	Gordon Hodgson	19	16	3	84.21%
11	Gary McAllister	6	5	1	83.33%
12	Steven Gerrard	57	47	10	82.46%
13	Terry McDermott	20	16	4	80%
14	Dirk Kuyt	10	8	2	80%
15	Robbie Fowler	26	20	6	76.92%
16	Billy Liddell	45	34	11	75.56%
17	Bob Done	8	6	2	75%
18	Phil Neal	51	38	13	74.51%
19	Alec Lindsay	11	8	3	72.73%
20	Arthur Goddard	11	8	3	72.73%
21	Tommy Smith	32	22	10	68.75%
22	John Barnes	15	10	5	66.67%
23	Peter Beardsley	6	4	2	66.67%
24	Jack Balmer	6	4	2	66.67%
25	Kevin Keegan	17	11	6	64.71%
26	Jackie Sheldon	11	7	4	63.64%
27	Tommy Robertson	5	3	2	60%
28	Tommy Lucas	5	3	2	60%
29	Alf West	7	4	3	57.14%
30	Michael Owen	23	13	10	56.52%
31	Sam Raybould	11	6	5	54.55%
32	Ronnie Moran	15	8	7	53.33%
33	Donald McKinlay	8	4	4	50%
34	Tom Chorlton	8	4	4	50%
35	Ian Rush	6	3	3	50%
36	Dick Forshaw	5	2	3	40%

This list includes players who have scored 5+ penalties.