| Player | Goals | Date | Result | Opposition |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Roberto Firmino | 1 | 28 May 2023 | 4 - 4 | Southampton |
| Takumi Minamino | 1 | 17 May 2022 | 2 - 1 | Southampton |
| Dominic Solanke | 1 | 13 May 2018 | 4 - 0 | Brighton & Hove Albion |
| Jordon Ibe | 1 | 15 May 2016 | 1 - 1 | West Bromwich Albion |
| Mamadou Sakho | 1 | 20 Apr 2016 | 4 - 0 | Everton |
| Steven Gerrard | 1 | 24 May 2015 | 1 - 6 | Stoke City |
| Suso | 1 | 23 Sep 2014 | 2 - 2 | Middlesbrough |
| Daniel Agger | 1 | 11 May 2014 | 2 - 1 | Newcastle United |
| Peter Crouch | 1 | 26 Apr 2008 | 2 - 2 | Birmingham City |
| Djibril Cissé | 1 | 13 May 2006 | 3 - 3 | West Ham United |
| Vladimir Smicer | 1 | 25 May 2005 | 3 - 3 | AC Milan |
| Michael Owen | 1 | 15 May 2004 | 1 - 1 | Newcastle United |
| Nicolas Anelka | 1 | 11 May 2002 | 5 - 0 | Ipswich Town |
| Layton Maxwell | 1 | 21 Sep 1999 | 4 - 2 | Hull City |
| Karl-Heinz Riedle | 2 | 21 Sep 1999 | 4 - 2 | Hull City |
| Paul Ince | 1 | 16 May 1999 | 3 - 0 | Wimbledon |
| Jan Mølby | 1 | 14 Mar 1995 | 2 - 3 | Coventry City |
| Dean Saunders | 1 | 05 Sep 1992 | 2 - 1 | Chelsea |
| David Speedie | 1 | 11 May 1991 | 2 - 0 | Tottenham Hotspur |
| John Aldridge | 1 | 12 Sep 1989 | 9 - 0 | Crystal Palace |
| Colin Irwin | 1 | 05 May 1981 | 2 - 1 | Middlesbrough |
| Peter Cormack | 1 | 27 Dec 1975 | 1 - 0 | Manchester City |
| Bobby Graham | 1 | 26 Feb 1972 | 3 - 0 | Manchester City |
| Ian St John | 1 | 23 Jan 1971 | 3 - 0 | Swansea City |
| John Sealey | 1 | 26 Apr 1965 | 3 - 1 | Wolves |
| Kevin Baron | 1 | 16 Jan 1954 | 1 - 2 | Preston North End |
| Bill Kinghorn | 1 | 22 Apr 1939 | 1 - 1 | Sunderland |
| James Jackson | 1 | 18 Apr 1933 | 1 - 3 | Huddersfield Town |
| Alan Scott | 1 | 06 Apr 1931 | 1 - 4 | Manchester United |
| Bob Clark | 1 | 28 Mar 1931 | 3 - 1 | Portsmouth |
| Albert Whitehurst | 1 | 02 Feb 1929 | 2 - 2 | Leeds United |
| Jimmy Dawson | 1 | 15 Apr 1914 | 1 - 2 | Manchester United |
| Bertram Goode | 1 | 28 Dec 1909 | 2 - 4 | Sheffield United |
| Bill McPherson | 1 | 20 Apr 1908 | 2 - 0 | Chelsea |
| Sam Raybould | 1 | 27 Apr 1907 | 2 - 2 | Sheffield United |
| Bob Blanthorne | 1 | 17 Apr 1907 | 2 - 4 | Middlesbrough |
| Thomas Green | 1 | 03 Jan 1903 | 1 - 3 | Blackburn Rovers |
| Johnny Walker | 1 | 26 Apr 1902 | 1 - 1 | Blackburn Rovers |
| Frank Becton | 1 | 16 Apr 1898 | 4 - 0 | Aston Villa |
| Ben Bull | 1 | 25 Jan 1896 | 6 - 1 | Lincoln City |
| Douglas Dick | 1 | 24 Mar 1894 | 2 - 0 | Crewe Alexandra |
| John Miller | 1 | 15 Apr 1893 | 1 - 1 | Southport |
| Jock Smith | 1 | 25 Mar 1893 | 2 - 1 | Rossendale |